Five Umpiring Veterans Take Legal Action
Five former Major League Baseball umpires have taken legal action against their retirement plan. Joe West, Gerry Davis, Tom Hallion, Jerry Layne, and Larry Vanover filed a lawsuit on Sept. 29 in a New York federal court. They allege that their retirement benefits were incorrectly calculated under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974.
Their lawyer, Paul B. Holmes, explained that the total amount owed to the five officials exceeds 2 million dollars. Holmes noted that while some details could be viewed differently, certain areas showed that the umpires were simply shorted on their money.
Tense Exchanges Before The Lawsuit
Joe West shared details about how discussions went before the court filing. When he initially raised the issue with the retirement committee, he received an offer for a relatively small sum.
West stated that Major League Baseball senior vice president Steven Gonzalez told him, "If you don't like the number, sue us." West responded by asking, "Does Steve Gonzalez not know my history with dealing with lawsuits?" West holds the record for officiating 5,460 regular season games between 1976 and 2021. He previously won 500,000 dollars in damages in 2021 after a defamation suit against former player Paul Lo Duca.
Major League Baseball declined to comment on the matter, pointing to the ongoing lawsuit.
Failed Settlement Talks And Union Stance
The legal action targets the American Leagues and National Leagues of Professional Baseball Clubs Retirement Income Plan for Umpires, along with its retirement committee. Holmes mentioned that settlement talks were held prior to court action. The former umpires were prepared to accept less than full entitlement to settle out of court, but the offers from the league were not competitive.
The Major League Baseball Umpires Association has chosen not to join the case. Holmes explained that the union preferred to stay out of the conflict because it is not a large union and does not specialize in pensions.
Looking Ahead To Court Dates
The five officials retired at different points in recent years. West and Davis ended their careers after the 2021 season, while Hallion retired after 2022. Layne and Vanover finished their work at the end of 2024.
The case is now moving forward in the legal system. U.S. District Judge Ronnie Abrams has scheduled a pretrial conference for Dec. 11.
Read next
- Football predictions today
- Jackpot predictions this week
- MLB and every other league
- MLB official website
Good to know: We are not paid for any link on this page.
Be the first to comment
Tell us who you think wins and why. Keep it friendly. Links are removed on their own.
Note: comments are the writer own opinion, not ours, and never a tip from us.
18+Read this before you bet
- There are no sure bets. Every tip on this page is a chance worked out from data about the next game. A tip at 70 percent still loses about three times in ten. Anyone selling a sure bet or a fixed match is lying.
- Betting is not income. Never bet to pay rent, school fees or a loan, and never borrow to bet, including from mobile loan apps.
- 18 and over only. Betting under 18 is illegal in Kenya.
- Use licensed bookmakers. Only bet with operators licensed by the Gambling Regulatory Authority of Kenya. Prices here can change before you bet, so check them first.
- Gambling can be addictive. If it stops being fun, stop. Read our responsible betting page or visit Responsible Gaming Federation of Kenya.
Good to know: We are not a bookmaker and we do not take bets. Full details are in our disclaimer.
